Timeline: How the murder case of Middletown 6-year-old James Hutchinson unfolded

Credit: Journal News

Caption
Candlelight vigil held in memory of 6-year-old James Hutchinson

Credit: Journal News

A Middletown woman drove to a Preble County wildlife area to abandon her 6-year-old son and possibly his siblings but ran over him and killed him when he tried to get back in the car, according to police and court records.

Brittany Gosney, 29, of the 500 block of Crawford Street, is charged with murder, abuse of corpse and tampering with evidence for the death of her child, James Robert Hutchinson. Her boyfriend, James Hamilton, 42, is charged with abuse of a corpse and tampering with evidence.

They are accused of moving the boy’s body back to Middletown after his death in Preble County, driving it to Indiana and disposing of it in the Ohio River on Saturday.

Here’s how the case unfolded (continue below):

Feb. 26 or Feb. 27: His death

According to the Preble County Sheriff’s Office report, Gosney said she was under pressure from Hamilton to get rid of Hutchinson and his two siblings, ages 9 and 7. The 29-year-old mother drove the three children in a 2005 Dodge Caravan to Rush Run to abandon them, according to Middletown and Preble reports.

“The defendant admitted to taking her child to Rush Run in Preble County where she placed him outside of her vehicle. Defendant said she was going to leave the child in the park,” Detective Jon Hoover wrote in the court documents.

The boy attempted to get back in the vehicle, and Gosney told police she sped off, dragging James “for a distance.”

Gosney told police she left the park and returned about 30 to 40 minutes later and found the boy in the middle of the parking lot with a head injury. He was dead, police said.

“(Gosney) stated she picked the child up, put him back in the vehicle and drove back (to her residence) where she took the child in the house and placed him in an upstairs bedroom,” the complaint states.

Brittany Gosney and James Hamilton were charged on Sunday, Feb. 28, 2021 in connection to the death of 6-year-old James Robert Hutchinson of Middletown. Brittany Gosney admitted to taking her child to Rush Run in Preble County where she placed him outside of her vehicle. She said she was going to leave the child in the park. NICK GRAHAM / STAFF
Caption
Brittany Gosney and James Hamilton were charged on Sunday, Feb. 28, 2021 in connection to the death of 6-year-old James Robert Hutchinson of Middletown. Brittany Gosney admitted to taking her child to Rush Run in Preble County where she placed him outside of her vehicle. She said she was going to leave the child in the park. NICK GRAHAM / STAFF

Saturday, Feb. 27 into Sunday, Feb. 28: Disposal in Ohio River

Police believe that sometime Saturday night after the other kids fell asleep, the co-defendants drove James’ body to the Ohio River.

10:17 a.m., Sunday, Feb. 28: Reported missing

Gosney reports Hutchinson missing since 9 p.m. the previous day. She told police she “just woke up and he’s gone,” according to police records.

She said he was wearing a plain red shirt and Batman pants and they had been searching for several hours.

9:10 p.m., Sunday, Feb. 28: Charges announced

Middletown police release a statement that Gosney and Hamilton have been arrested and charged in Hutchinson’s death. After days of rain and large amounts of melted snow, they say they are searching the river but that the “river is very high and treacherous, so we will not be disclosing the exact location in hopes of avoiding another tragic incident.”

9:45 a.m. Monday, March 1: Details first reported

From the criminal complaint, the Journal-News first reports the details about Gosney’s claims she tried to abandon Hutchinson before running him over.

11:07 a.m., Monday, March 1: School district releases statement

Hutchinson was a first-grader at Rosa Parks Elementary School.

“James was a happy and joyful soul who loved school,” Tracey Neeley, principal of the school, said in a statement. “On the days he was in class, he would give hugs to all his teachers as he walked into school.”

“A fun memory I have is the way his face would light up when he won the lucky lunch tray! First-graders can find the joy in just about anything. I will always remember his bright joy,” said Neeley.

1:30 p.m., Monday, March 1: Defendants appear in court for the first time

During the arraignment in Middletown Municipal Court, Judge James Sherron set Gosney’s bond at $1 million and Hamilton’s bond at $105,000.

Caption
Brittany Gosney was charged with murder and other charges after the death of her 6-year-old son, James Hutchinson

2:30 p.m. Monday, March 1: Officials hold first news conference

Middletown Police Chief David Birk, Preble County Sheriff Mike Simpson and Middletown Schools Superintendent Marlon Styles Jr. gather the media to share more details.

Birk said two of the boy’s siblings, a boy and girl under the age of 10, were in the vehicle when James was struck, and it appears she may have been trying to leave all three of her children.

“I don’t know if she had a plan,” Birk said.

Hamilton admitted to police he kept the boy’s body in the Crawford Street house and then took part in disposing of it in the Ohio River, according to court documents filed by Hoover.

“The mother is not showing much remorse at this time, but she has confessed to doing this, we will know more once James is recovered and we can do an autopsy,” Birk said.

Photos from the news conference regarding the death of 6-year-old James Robert Hutchinson of Middletown. NICK GRAHAM / STAFF
Caption
Photos from the news conference regarding the death of 6-year-old James Robert Hutchinson of Middletown. NICK GRAHAM / STAFF

7 p.m. Monday, March 1: Vigil held at Gardner Park

The community released balloons, lit candles and held a moment of silence.

Lewis Hutchinson, James Hutchinson’s father, said his son brought joy to those around him.

“The whole room could be down in the dumps and he could bring joy to all of them,” he said. “He was really funny, he loved to gives hugs to everyone, he was a great kid.”

Lewis Hutchinson shared his desire for justice for his son.

“I don’t know how to process this, I want justice for him, that’s what I want,” he said.

Lewis Hutchinson, the father of James Hutchinson, speaks to media as over 100 people attended a vigil for a Middletown child who was allegedly killed by his mother. The community released balloons, lit candles and held a moment of silence at the vigil at Gardner Park Monday evening.

James Robert Hutchinson was reported missing on Sunday to Middletown police, but detective interviews with the boy’s mother, Brittany Gosney, 29, and James Hamilton, 42, determined James was killed a few days before in Preble County. The child’s body was returned to Middletown and later put in the Ohio River, according to Middletown police. NICK GRAHAM / STAFF
Caption
Lewis Hutchinson, the father of James Hutchinson, speaks to media as over 100 people attended a vigil for a Middletown child who was allegedly killed by his mother. The community released balloons, lit candles and held a moment of silence at the vigil at Gardner Park Monday evening. James Robert Hutchinson was reported missing on Sunday to Middletown police, but detective interviews with the boy’s mother, Brittany Gosney, 29, and James Hamilton, 42, determined James was killed a few days before in Preble County. The child’s body was returned to Middletown and later put in the Ohio River, according to Middletown police. NICK GRAHAM / STAFF

Credit: Nick Graham

Credit: Nick Graham

6:45 p.m., Tuesday, March 2: Vigil at Barnitz Stadium

The district organized the event at which school officials gave statements from a podium next to a large painting of Hutchinson — the artwork was done this week by high school students in Rick Krebs’ art class — who was described as a happy, fun, bright and well-liked student.

“We are heartbroken and there is a long road of healing for all of us,” Rosa Parks Principal Tracy Neeley said before introducing the staff members who knew James best, his first-grade teacher Shawn Kavanaugh and kindergarten teacher Leigh Phieffer.

Friday, March 5: Fund established for Hutchinson’s siblings

The “James You Are Loved Fund” was set up Middletown schools, Middletown police, the city and local faith-based groups.

How to donate:

  • Visit or send an e-check to any First Financial Bank Branch using the name “James You Are Loved Memorial Fund.”
  • Mail a physical check to Middletown City School District, One Donham Plaza, 4th Floor, Middletown, OH 45042 to the attention of “James You Are Loved Memorial Fund.”
  • Donate online

Friday, March 5: Gosney and Hamilton indicted

They were indicted by a Butler County grand jury on a total of 31 felony charges for the death Hutchinson and crimes against his siblings.

Sunday, March 7: Search resumes

After several days of the Ohio River’s height preventing a search for Hutchinson’s body, the search resumes near Lawrenceburg, Indiana with multiple agencies contributing.

ajc.com

Monday, March 8: Arraignment

Court-appointed attorneys entered not guilty pleas on behalf of Gosney and Hamilton in Judge Noah Powers’ courtroom. Bond was set at $2 million for Gosney and $750,000 for Hamilton.

About the Author