Sheriff: Butler County on the ‘naughty list’ prohibited from sending inmates to state prisons

Credit: DaytonDailyNews

the recently added body scanner at the Butler County Jail has potential to increase security for inmates and corrections officers.

Credit: DaytonDailyNews

The Butler County Jail is one of several in the state banned from transporting inmates to state prisons after multiple positive coronavirus tests, but the sheriff says that is hurting the jail operations.

Butler County Sheriff Richards Jones says he believes the testing system is flawed, and the inability to transfer those sentenced to prison to those state facilities is affecting space at the county jail for local prisoners.

Explore37 people indicted in Butler and Warren counties

“We call it being on the naughty list,” Jones said of facilities unable to transfer inmates to the state prison system.

During Thanksgiving week, 28 people given prison sentences by Butler County Common Pleas judges remained in the local jail because ODRC has prohibited any transfer from the county facility since the end of October.

On Monday, that number rose to 42, according to Chief Deputy Anthony Dwyer.

Jones said it is the job of the prison system to house those sentenced by judges to the penitentiary. The sheriff began is career in the state prison system, serving as a major at Lebanon Correctional Institution in the 1990s.

“Butler County is not currently permitted to send us incarcerated adults,” said ODRC Director Annette Chambers-Smith. “This is as a result of positive cases being sent to us, as well as how much COVID is in the facility, how many staff and incarcerated people are positive in the facility they are coming from. It is a totality of circumstances and culminates in us receiving positives from another congregate setting.”

In addition to Butler, Ross and Clermont counties are also currently prohibited. Montgomery County has been prohibited for a couple of weeks but is expected to transport prisoners from the county facility to the state system this week, she said.

Since the March, 23 county jails have been under periods of prohibition from transporting prisoners due to positive test results, according to prison officials.

ExploreProsecutor: Middletown officer shooting case expected at grand jury by year’s end

Chambers-Smith said the department has a team to work with county jails to return conditions to the point inmates can be transferred.

“This is the first time Butler County has been on restriction. Even when they sent us a positive person in the summer, we worked with them collaboratively to try to keep them turned on and make sure the systems and precautions were in place,” she said.

The director said Butler County is a “very well run facility. But, what we are taking about is COVID procedures. We are both operating congregate settings, and when someone is positive and moves from a county jail to a prison, they have that (person) to infect a new congregate (setting). And that (facility) sends people to all the prisons in the state as well as back home. It is not just about one person.”

Jones said he doesn’t believe any coronavirus-positive inmates were transported to ODRC.

“We don’t believe their tests are accurate. We even offered to go up and test them ourselves. Because you can get a false (result),” he said

Jones estimated that housing the 28 prisoners sentenced to ODRC has cost the county about $300,000, and he is going to bill them “for every cent. I probably won’t get it, but I will try.”

Coronavirus quarantine has decreased the county jail’s available space, and keeping inmates who should be in prison is making matters worse, he said.

“They (ODRC) will not communicate with us, they will not cooperate. They dictate these rules and they change all the time,” Jones said.

He added the prison system has more space, resources and even hospital facilities to care for sick prisoners.

Jones said new procedures are in place, including testing people before transport, but it can take three to five days to get tests back. So when they are retested in prison, it is possible they were exposed en route or even at the prison reception area.

“If there is not enough room in the jail, they have to get released. If we are keeping prisoners that should be in the prison, eventually there’s going to be no room in the jail,” Jones said.

ExploreOhio lawmakers consider lessening penalties, encouraging treatment for low-level drug offenses

In Other News