Man convicted of 2 murders pleads not guilty to killing fellow inmate

He was in jail for killing his girlfriend’s mother and setting her on fire

Two days after inmate Casey Pigge appeared in court wearing a straitjacket and agreed to spend the rest of his life in prison, he strangled another prisoner to death in the back of a state prison bus, Pickaway County prosecutors allege.

Pigge, 29, is pleading not guilty to an aggravated murder charge. A pre-trial hearing was held Friday in Pickaway County.

Related: New Details: Prosecutor blasts prison officials over inmate death

Pigge entered state prison in November 2009 to begin serving a 41 years to life sentence for killing his girlfriend’s mother and setting her on fire.

On Feb. 23, 2016, Pigge used a cement block to beat to death his cellmate, Luther Wade, of Springfield, while at Lebanon Correctional Institution. He pleaded guilty to Wade’s murder on Jan. 30.

Recommended for you

Recommended for you

Recommended for you

Most read

  1. 1 Ex-Hamilton superintendent accused of sexual harassment, more
  2. 2 Father/daughter charged with theft of tools bound to grand jury
  3. 3 Middletown airport becomes federal 'opportunity zone'

Pigge’s low IQ prevented prosecutors from seeking the death penalty against him in his previous cases.

Related: Inmate avoids potential death penalty

He was being transported on Feb. 1 to the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility in Lucasville after his sentencing in the Wade murder when he allegedly killed David Johnson.

Related: Inmate’s third murder investigation returned to Ross County

Johnson, who was serving eight years in prison for sexual battery, had been admitted to prison in December 2015.

Pigge, Johnson and several other inmates were in the back compartments of a prison bus, said Pickaway County Prosecutor Judy Wolford. There were no cameras, she said.

Pigge is already serving life in prison — the same sentence he might face if he is convicted of Johnson’s murder.

Wolford said the case should still be prosecuted. “You still have a victim. He still killed someone.”

The state prison department has declined to release its transportation policy, citing exceptions to the Ohio Records law that allow withholding of security documents.

More from Journal-news