Albert B. Oberst, wearing an eye patch, gave a pocket watch to his son, Jim Oberst, middle back row. Oberst then gave the watch to his son, Albert Oberst. The watch was stolen 23 years ago during a home invasion, then it turned up recently in Middletown. SUBMITTED PHOTO
Photo: Submitted photo
Photo: Submitted photo

A priceless heirloom was stolen 23 years ago in Kentucky. Then it was found in Middletown.

If only this pocket watch could talk. The tales it would tell.

Stolen 23 years ago during a home burglary in Lexington, Kentucky, the Elgin pocket watch has been returned to its owner thanks to an inquisitive — and thoughtful — Middletown man.

Let’s start this story by turning the clock back to 1996.

Albert B. Oberst, 59, who owns a sign business in Lexington, said when he and his wife returned home after dinner one Saturday night, they interrupted a home invasion. The thieves only had time to steal his wife’s costume jewelry and a pocket watch that was displayed in a glass case off his dresser.

MORE McCRABB: This Butler County couple are both organ donors. Here’s their inspiring story.

But this was no ordinary pocket watch. It was a family heirloom that had been passed down to three generations from Albert Benedict Oberst to his son, Jim Oberst, to his grandson, Albert Oberst. The watch was inscribed with Oberst’s grandfather’s name, Albert Benedict Oberst, and Owensboro, the city where he practiced law his entire life.

This Elgin pocket watch was stolen during a home invasion 23 years ago in Lexington. A Middletown man, Larry Glenn, was recently given the watch as collateral and he tracked down the original owners. SUBMITTED PHOTO
Photo: Staff Writer

The attorney, then in his 40s, was shot while sitting at the dining room table, an incident that cost him his left eye but didn’t end his law practice, his grandson said.

Oberst said he dreamed of carrying on the family tradition and passing the pocket watch down to the next generation if he had a son.

For days after the burglary, Oberst searched Lexington pawn shops hoping to find the stolen watch. Eventually, he gave up.

“I figured it was lost forever,” Oberst said.

That’s where the story could have ended.


But 23 years later and 120 miles away in Middletown, Larry Glenn got into a dispute with a home improvement contractor who was given a $200 down payment to repair Glenn’s basement drywall. But the contractor never completed the work, and when Glenn confronted the man, the contractor offered an antique pocket watch as collateral.

You guessed.

The stolen watch.

MORE McCRABB: This Middletown golf club has grown from near bankruptcy to growth in 5 years. Meet the man behind it.

When Glenn opened the pocket watch’s cover, he noticed someone had etched the message: “Albert Benedict Oberst, Owensboro.”

The watch, Glenn said, was “pretty cool” and he realized it probably had sentimental value to the Oberst family.

Glenn took photos of the watch and inscription, then searched the Internet for anyone with a matching name. Thankfully, there aren’t many people named Albert Oberst out there.

Glenn found an Albert Oberst III, who had just moved to New York City. On Facebook, he sent Oberst a picture of the watch and asked if he knew its history.

Earlier this month, members of the Oberst family drove to Middletown to purchase a pocket watch from Larry Glenn, who received the watch as collateral from a contractor. Here, Lauren Anderkin holds the watch that was stolen 23 years ago from her father’s home in Lexington. SUBMITTED PHOTO
Photo: Staff Writer

Since the 22-year-old wasn’t born when the watch was stolen, he forwarded the message and picture to his father in Lexington.

“Does this mean anyone to you?” he wrote to his father.

“OMG,” his father wrote back. “That is the watch.”

MORE: ‘We’re adrenaline junkies’: For one day, this father-son pair worked on the same Middletown medic unit

His father called the watch “a priceless heirloom.”

Oberst and Glenn communicated on the Internet and they agreed $200 was a fair price for the watch, the same amount Glenn paid the contractor. Oberst’s daughter and son-in-law, Lauren and Aaron Anderkin, met Glenn at his home earlier this month after going to a Cincinnati Reds game, the Cincinnati Zoo and Cincinnati Premium Outlets.

“It couldn’t have worked out more perfect,” Glenn said. “It was meant to happen the way it did.”

Glenn never hesitated returning the watch.

“It really belongs to them,” he said. “To me, some things you can’t buy. It wasn’t about the money. Family means the most to me.”

You may remember Larry Glenn. Two years ago, he thwarted a home burglary in Middletown by entering his neighbor’s home and confronting the suspect with a loaded gun. After cocking the gun, Glenn said the suspect “got the message” and surrendered.

When asked about his two Good Samaritan efforts, Glenn said, “I always believe in doing the right thing. I was raised that way.

“I guess it was my time.”

Thank you for reading the Journal-News and for supporting local journalism. Subscribers: log in for access to your daily ePaper and premium newsletters.

Thank you for supporting in-depth local journalism with your subscription to the Journal-News. Get more news when you want it with email newsletters just for subscribers. Sign up here.