Aerial scenes of Central Ave business district downtown Middletown

Police investigation: Dispute over $10 leads to deadly Middletown shooting

Police were called at 7:44 p.m. Monday to the 1400 block of Yankee Road, where they found John Booker, 36, seriously injured from gunfire. He was taken to a local hospital, where he later died.

Detectives were looking for suspect Dhameer Haamid Scott, 24, of Prospect Avenue, all day Tuesday and released his photo asking people to call if they knew his whereabouts. On Wednesday, Scott turned himself into police. He is charged with murder.

FIRST REPORT: Middletown man shot and killed, police looking for suspect 

A call placed to 911 indicates witnesses at the residence named Scott as the person who shot Booker. A woman reported her son had been shot and was lying in the yard.

“There has been a shooting at my house, I need an ambulance,” the woman told dispatchers. “There was an altercation in the home and he got shot.”

Dhameer Haamid Scott MIDDLETOWN DIVISION OF POLICE
Photo: Staff Writer

According to police, Booker’s mother, Vicki, and Scott’s father, Desmont Johnson Sr., lived at the Yankee Road address. On Monday, Scott came to the house and dropped off $30 for his younger brother, Desmont Johnson Jr.

When Booker arrived at the house, he took $10 from the cash that was sitting on the shelf, according to Johnson Sr. Booker was told to put the money back but refused, Johnson Sr. told police.

Johnson Sr. called Scott and told him that Booker had taken the money.

MORE: Warren County Jail inmate now a fugitive; do you know his whereabouts

“Johnson Sr. advised Dhameer Scott and another friend of Scott’s arrived together (at the residence) and Scott entered the residence with a gun in his hand,” Detective Steve Winters wrote in the court document outlining the charge against Scott.

A verbal altercation began between Scott and Booker then turned physical, police said. That’s when Vicki Booker attempted to intervene, and both left the residence and were fighting on the front porch.

“Johnson Sr. stated he then heard a gunshot, and John Booker screamed out to call the police he had been hit,” according to court documents.

Detectives spoke to Johnson Jr., who said after the shooting he received a call from Scott, who told him he had to shoot Booker, “due to Booker stealing his money,” according to court documents.

MORE: WATCH: Video shows events before deputy shoots man in park after commands ignored

Thank you for reading the Journal-News and for supporting local journalism. Subscribers: log in for access to your daily ePaper and premium newsletters.

Thank you for supporting in-depth local journalism with your subscription to the Journal-News. Get more news when you want it with email newsletters just for subscribers. Sign up here.