Demolition of former mall to begin next week

O’Rourke Wrecking Co. contracted to take down the mall, parking garage
The former Forest Fair Mall and its four-story parking garage will be demolished in two weeks by O’Rourke Wrecking Co. They have erected fencing around the perimeter of the demolition area. SUE KIESEWETTER/CONTRIBUTED

The former Forest Fair Mall and its four-story parking garage will be demolished in two weeks by O’Rourke Wrecking Co. They have erected fencing around the perimeter of the demolition area. SUE KIESEWETTER/CONTRIBUTED

The former Cincinnati Mall or Forest Fair Mall is coming down soon.

Demolition of the 1.5 million square-foot mall that straddles the Hamilton County-Butler County line, and its four-story parking garage is slated to begin next week, developers say.

“We’re very excited and pleased that this dead mall is finally going to be coming down,’' said Greg Kathman, Fairfield’s director of development services.

The work will be done by the O’Rourke Wrecking Co. and is expected to take 10 months to complete, said Ben Davis, senior vice president of Hillwood.

O’Rourke has already erected fencing around the mall and garage with no trespassing signs posted around the perimeter of the demolition area.

Even though most of the 90-acre site was largely in Hamilton County at its border with Fairfield along South Gilmore Road, Butler County’s land bank obtained a $7.9 million state grant to be put toward demolition costs, expected to top $10 million.

That money must be spent by July 1, 2026, after the land bank got an extension, said David Fehr, Butler County’s director of development.

“From our perspective, that property is the front door leading into Butler County,’’ Fehr said.

“Cincinnati Financial has their offices near there in Fairfield. The property was becoming a bit of an eyesore — they weren’t maintaining it properly.”

The mall opened in 1989 and has gone through several ownership changes with a major renovation completed in 2004. Owners struggle to attract tenants, resulted in its decline.

The Fairfield Fire Department condemned the parking garage in 2018. The mall’s interior was closed three years ago after Forest Park condemned it due to health and safety concerns.

The last two tenants — Bass Pro Shops and Kohl’s — left in January 2024 and March of this year, respectively.

Cincinnati Mall, formerly Forest Fair Mall, situated on the border of Forest Park and Fairfield could soon be demolished to make space for redevelopment. NICK GRAHAM/STAFF

Credit: Nick Graham

icon to expand image

Credit: Nick Graham

The City of Forest Park shared some "final walk-through" photos on Facebook on Aug. 22, 2025 showing the former Forest Fair Mall/Cincinnati Mills Mall ahead of its demolition. The mall, which straddles the Forest Park and Fairfield border, originally opened in phases in 1988-89 and was a landmark, the second-largest mall in Ohio at the time. It featured up to 200 stores in more than 1.5 million square feet. CONTRIBUTED/FOREST PARK

icon to expand image

Earlier this month Hillwood Investment Properties closed on the eastern 60 acres of the site. The rest of the acreage — fronting South Gilmore Road — is still owned by New York-based World Properties LLC.

Last month The Hillman Group signed a lease for a 716,000 square-foot building with Hillwood Investment Group, a Texas-based Perot company.

Hillman, a Cincinnati-based hardware distributor, plans to gradually consolidate some of its operations to the Hillwood site.

Davis said additional plans for the property would be released at a later date.

About the Author