If it’s not the switch, you really need to have the car’s computer scanned for stored faults. For instance, a scan could reveal that it’s a faulty solenoid, a failed transfer case actuator motor or a bad computer.
Or, as I said earlier, you could have lunched the center differential when you got towed. That’s thousands of dollars. In that case, you probably could just apply the “black tape solution” to the light and drive the car until it drops. A car that’s old enough to vote is hardly worth putting a new all-wheel-drive transmission in.
If the differential is cooked, the towing took place recently and you know who towed you, you can try making a claim against them in small claims court – if they haven’t closed up shop and fled to Saskatchewan.
That’s assuming you didn’t tow it yourself, Henry, or give the driver permission to tow it on the front wheels because there was no flat bed available and you really wanted to get home in time to watch “60 Minutes.” I’ll cross my fingers for a bad switch for you.
Do the new stop-start features on cars wear out engine parts faster?
Dear Car Talk:
I have a 2017 Jeep Cherokee V-6 with the automatic stop-start feature. Which is best in the long run: Disable the feature so that the engine continues to run at stoplights, just like all the previous cars I've had, or let it shut itself down and then restart when I take my foot off the brake? Is the amount of gas saved at a two- or, very occasionally, three-minute stoplight better than the added use of the starter? Does this cause enough added wear and tear on the engine to be concerned about? – Joseph
RAY: These stop-start systems are just a few years old now, so I'll reserve the right to change my mind if evidence to the contrary piles up. But from what I've seen so far, the starting systems have been beefed up enough to handle the extra starts without any sort of long-term issues.
So if there’s really no penalty for stopping and restarting the car when you’re not moving, then why not save the extra fuel – as well as the wear and tear on the engine?
More importantly, when the engine is off, you’re not creating any pollution. And in cities, if we collectively reduce car-generated air pollution by 3 to 5 percent, that’d be great.
The only reason we’ve had to turn off stop-start systems in cars we test-drive is that they can be annoying. Some are better than others. Many are subtle enough that you very quickly get used to it; others start with a 1.1-Richter shudder that makes you want to run under a doorway to protect yourself. I imagine that all of these systems will continue to improve over time to where they’re not only tolerable, but we basically forget all about them.
So unless the restart is so extreme that it’s causing you neck pain, Joseph, use it, save the fuel and cut the pollution.