Thames hit two home runs against Garrett, who was a starting pitcher then, on April 24, 2017. Thames hit a solo home run in the first and then a two-run home run in the second inning. Garrett then walked Thames in the fourth.
This time, Garrett said he just made a bad pitch: a fastball over the middle.
“I definitely know with my stuff I can get him out,” Garrett said. “That’s what happens when you leave it over the middle against a hitter like that. All he has to do is touch it. I supply the speed. He has the power. It’s going to happen.”
» PHOTOS: Reds vs. Brewers
Thames has 62 home runs in five seasons, and 21 percent of them are against the Reds. He also has hit home runs against Bronson Arroyo, Wandy Peralta, Tony Cingrani, Tim Adleman, Robert Stephenson (2), Blake Wood, Kevin Shackelford, Sal Romano and Tyler Mahle.
Six of Thames’ 13 home runs have tied the game or given the Brewers the lead.
“Thames has really done damage against us last year and this year,” Reds interim manager Jim Riggleman said. “We just haven’t had an answer for him. He’s really hurt us. You get to a point here where you’ve just got to tip your cap to him because he’s really done the job against us.”
» REDS NEWS: Senzel has surgery | Suarez trying to enjoy moment | Casali thriving in backup role
The left-handed Garrett (0-1, 2.76) said he doesn’t talk to the pitching staff as a whole about Thames because the Reds only have two lefties. Reliever Kyle Crockett is the other.
“I can’t really ask the guys, ‘What do you guys throw to him?,’ because they’re righties,’” Garrett said. “We have video and stuff like that, but the stuff that may have got him out before may not get him out tonight.”
Despite suffering his first loss, Garrett remains one of the most dependable pitchers in the bullpen. The last 10 times he had pitched, the Reds had won each game. Prior to this game, he had stranded 25 of the 28 runners he inherited.
This was his first appearance since Tuesday when he was hit by a ball below the knee. He left the game with a contusion but said he’s good to go now. He was eager to get another chance soon.
“That’s what I love about being in the bullpen,” Garrett said. “I’m going to come out there tomorrow and look for a little revenge and take it out on whoever’s out there at bat.”