RELATED: Trump is right: bigotry, violence ‘on many sides’
This option might not work for very large statues, but where possible it could be a good way to help museum-goers visualize historical figures and understand government’s endorsement of and participation in racial oppression in American history.
2. Use the statues in new art with new meaning.
Alfredo Stroessner was a dictator who ruled the Latin American nation of Paraguay for several decades in the 20th century. He had political critics tortured and murdered, rigged elections and was generally so oppressive that his government was dubbed the “poor man’s Nazi regime.”
RELATED: Timeline: The wild 24 hours of Franklin’s Robert E. Lee Confederate monument
After Stroessner was ousted, Paraguayans understandably didn’t want statues honoring him in their public spaces. With one of them, they turned the image of the dictator and crushed it between massive concrete blocks, with him seeming to struggle to get free.
You don’t have to know much about art to get what that statue communicates about the regime. It’s an effective way to denounce historical abuses while maintaining an awareness of this painful history.
3. Put the statues in context in a “fallen monument park.”
Many former Soviet countries have been thinking about how to deal with statues of people like Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin for a lot longer than we’ve been having this Confederate statue debate. One solution they’ve developed in Russia, Hungary, Lithuania and Estonia is to create a “fallen monument park” that puts the statues in context.
READ THIS NEXT: Extremist groups in Ohio deny they package in hate
The context happens in two ways. First, “Each monument includes a plaque explaining when it was erected, how it was funded and that it has been preserved and installed in the park not to celebrate Stalin or Lenin or their ideas but because of its historical significance,” writes Radley Balko, who visited the fallen monument park in Moscow.
And second, the old statues of the Soviet leaders are accompanied by new statues of their victims. In Moscow, Balko says, “One statute of Stalin stands — minus its nose — in front of a harrowing sculpture depicting dozens of human heads stacked behind barbed wire. It’s a monument to the victims of totalitarianism.”
Here in the States, a fallen monument park could collect Confederate statues, removing them from places of undue honor, and give them a similar context. We could have signs explaining the relevant history as well as memorials to the victims of slavery and postbellum racial oppression. These options won’t satisfy everyone, of course, but for the bulk of people who want to reject racism while remembering history, they could do the trick.
Bonnie Kristian writes for Rare and The Week.