Carlisle school board accepts resignation of head football coach accused of theft at Beavercreek

The resignation of the newly hired head football coach at Carlisle High School was officially accepted by the school board during a special meeting Wednesday.

Thomas “T.J.” Smart, a longtime assistant football coach at several area high schools, had not coached a single down at Carlisle prior to his resignation last week following his arrest May 21 by Beavercreek police. Smart is accused of stealing about $600 in ticket sales proceeds following a May 9 girls lacrosse game from his full-time employer, Beavercreek Local Schools.

MORE: Carlisle official: Coach’s OVI conviction ‘not a disqualifier’ in hiring

After learning of the police investigation, Carlisle Superintendent Larry Hook placed him on administrative leave. Smart submitted his resignation as football coach for “personal reasons” on May 22.

Hook said a replacement for Smart as Carlisle’s head football coach is “to be determined.”

Smart was hired on Feb. 11, however, he would continue his “day job” with Beavercreek schools. Carlisle would have been his first head coaching job. He had been an assistant coach at several area schools, including Oakwood, Tipp City Bethel and Beavercreek.

He was put on paid administrative leave on May 21 from Beavercreek schools, where he has worked as a special education aide for nine years.

MORE: Carlisle football coach resigns after theft accusation, has 3 alcohol-related convictions since 2012

On May 21, a police officer escorted Smart from his Beavercreek High School classroom to the police department where he admitted to a detective that he stole the lacrosse game cash box from the athletic director’s office. He also admitted to taking adult and student ticket rolls and the ticket sales ledger.

Police said Smart used a master key for the high school building to gain entry to the office, to which he had access when he was a “site manager” for the district. He was no longer working in that capacity and should not have had access to it, according to the police report.

MORE: Carlisle football coach accused in theft was hired 3 months ago, stressed mentorship and character

Police recovered the ticket log from Smart’s vehicle and found the adult and student ticket rolls, both of which were used to determine how much money was taken, at his Kettering home, according to the report.

Smart was issued a summons to Fairborn Municipal Court on a charge of petty theft, a first-degree misdemeanor charge and released from custody.

Smart’s attorney entered an appearance for him on May 22 in Fairborn Municipal Court where he requested a pre-trial conference, demand for discovery and time waiver, and entered a not guilty plea. Court officials said Wednesday a pre-trial conference has not yet been scheduled.

Smart, a 2008 Fairmount graduate, has been convicted of three alcohol-related charges since 2012: an OVI charge in Kettering Municipal Court; a disorderly conduct/intoxication charge in Fairborn Municipal Court; and an additional OVI charge in Fairborn Municipal Court.

Hook said the district did an Ohio BCI background check on Smart and was aware of one OVI charge from his past during the interview process, but he said “that is not a disqualifier.”

MORE: Carlisle turns to a longtime assistant as new football coach

Hook said there was a discussion during Smart’s interview about the OVI issue and he was told “that can’t happen here.” He also said the district was not condoning Smart’s behavior, but felt like he made a mistake.

This report contains previous reporting by Staff Writer Richard Wilson.

About the Author