Combs said the commission also denied the site plan with the proposed parking in front and on the sides because it did not comply with requirements for the current zoning district.
Mallory Greenham, executive director of Downtown Middletown Inc., was one downtown business leader who spoke against the new business development.
“The prospect site for O’Reilly’s is the at the main entrance to the downtown Middletown historic business district,” she said. “What is built on that lot will serve as an unofficial gateway to downtown Middletown and will also set the tone for future infill development.”
Downtown Middletown Inc. attended the Historic Commission meeting to speak specifically on behalf of the new Downtown Master Plan, she said. The new downtown plan has is currently under review and has not yet been approved by City Council.
One aspect of the plan is bringing buildings close to the street with no parking lots in front, complementing and extending the existing urban development pattern, and minimizing the negative impact of parking.
MORE: What type of businesses have opened in downtown Middletown?
Mike Robinette, owner of the new Liberty Spirits distillery, also spoke at last week’s meeting, expressing concerns that the proposed design for the auto parts store did not jive with the downtown plan.
“We’re not opposed to an auto parts store,” he said. “We’re opposed to how this was presented and opposed to a strip mall.”
Robinette said he and other downtown stakeholders will strongly oppose this plan and, if needed, will engage legal counsel to stop the project as proposed.
RELATED: Middletown distillery seeks 10-year, 100 percent tax break
The developer could appeal the Historic Commission’s decision to the city Board of Zoning Appeals, according to Combs.
The city Planning & Zoning Department has not yet received an application from the representative of O’Reilly Auto Parts to be heard by the Board of Zoning Appeals.
“Even if the Board of Zoning Appeals approves variances that were requested and denied by the Historic Commission, O’Reilly will still need to get Historic Commission’s approval before being able to proceed with building the store,” Combs said.