Pitman: Newest Hamilton business investor says he is committed to city

Cincinnati-based real estate investor Ash Patel wanted to be a part of the Hamilton community as soon as he took his first tour.

He said he has an affinity for old buildings, and downtown Hamilton is pretty much exclusively old buildings. So when Pete Montgomery, a property manager with CMC Properties ― the developer of the Marcum Apartments and the under-construction Rossville Flats ― told him about the availability of High St. Cafe, he couldn’t get “I’ll take it” out fast enough.

The revitalization of Hamilton has been meteoric for the past decade. That secret sauce formula, many have said, consists of a mixture of the city administration led by City Manager Joshua Smith, the backing of City Council, buy-in from the community and outside investors, such as CMC Properties with the projects like the Marcum, willing to take a chance.

Oh, and the gigantic $165 million Spooky Nook Sports bringing in thousands of people on a weekend doesn’t hurt.

Add all of that up and that equals landing future investors such as Patel, who wants to be a part of Hamilton’s renaissance and the city’s anticipated larger success. He’s expected to take ownership of High St. Cafe by July 1 but hopes to name the future occupant weeks prior. Patel, though, doesn’t see it as taking a chance. It’s an opportunity.

“We tried to buy properties there for years and could never come to terms on prices,” said Patel, who’s been in the commercial real estate business full-time for more than a decade.

And the man who said, “I love downtown Hamilton,” isn’t in the City of Sculpture to make a quick buck, so don’t expect to see a national chain at 250 High St. He’s investing to be invested in the community.

To demonstrate what type of property owner he intended to be, he shared a recent experience at one of his area properties. The owner of a business lost her husband a year ago and wanted to sell, but she was at the end of the lease. A franchisee of a national pizza chain wanted to move into that spot.

Patel said, “No.”

“My operations manager came to me and said, ‘Are we gonna kick her out?” And I said, ‘Absolutely not.’ We don’t ruin people’s lives and businesses over money.”

They gave her a month-to-month lease while she worked to sell her business, and then he would work out an active lease agreement with whomever she sold the business to, Patel said.

With High St. Cafe, he’s not pushing for a national chain restaurant, which is not what most Hamiltonians want to see downtown. The main drag of Hamilton, from High Street to Main Street, is full of local business owners. They want something unique to Hamilton, and so does Patel.

“Money isn’t the ultimate motivator for me,” Patel said. “We have a lot of fun doing this, and we love hanging out with our tenants.”

Now, as the Spooky Nook complex draws more and more people to the city every weekend, and businesses and investors staking a claim anywhere in the city, Hamilton isn’t just growing. It’s glowing up. And there are many cheerleaders telling everyone about Hamilton, including Montgomery, ever since the Marcum Apartments opened in 2018.

“It’s an original downtown, it’s got that old-school feel. You feel like you’re in a different city when you’re there,” he said, adding that every weekend is “live” and “booming.”

“People are out, people are at the park, people are walking their dog,” Montgomery said. “It’s that feel that everybody wants. It’s Hamilton. It’s pretty amazing.”

And it started with somebody taking a chance.

About the Author