Bullington said thieves have taken all sorts of Jesus figures from the store, but the baby Jesus in the Nativity scene is the most popular.
"It's just crazy that people could steal baby Jesus," Bullington said. "And how could you not feel guilty about that?"
Store owners elsewhere have also complained that baby Jesus is stolen most often.
A number of stores in Washington state said in 2015 the figures were stolen from them as well. A Texas church had to leave a note asking that the replacement baby Jesus in a life-size nativity scene was left "for everybody to enjoy."