‘Cap and trade will prove exceptionally expensive for Ohio’

Palin's last laugh
11/20/09
‘With the help of Butler County United Way’
11/20/09
Honoring his family
11/19/09
‘It’s about character’
11/19/09
You're in denial
11/18/09
> More opinion headlines

1:37 PM Friday, June 19, 2009

Ohio’s electric cooperatives and Butler Rural Electric Cooperative support responsible congressional action on climate change that is affordable, achievable and effective.

HR 2454, the American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009, slated by Speaker Nancy Pelosi for floor action this summer, fails to meet those requirements. It will increase energy prices across the entire economy. Its near-term emission reduction targets cannot be met; and by design, it will take dollars from the Midwest and export them to coastal states and Washington, D.C.

HR 2454 requires a 17-percent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions below 2005 levels by 2020. Technology to accomplish this reduction cost-effectively for major sources of carbon emissions — power plants, industry and vehicles — does not exist. There is little likelihood that it will be developed or widely deployed by 2020.

Consequently, all petroleum and natural gas suppliers, industrial companies and carbon-based electric generation suppliers will be bidding for a declining sum of emission allowances set by the HR 2454 cap-and-trade system. Ohio’s electric cooperatives will have to purchase allowances or offsets for about half of their expected carbon-dioxide emissions in the first 10 years. And that percentage will grow over future years despite reductions achieved from energy conservation and noncarbon renewable energy.

Cap and trade will prove exceptionally expensive for Ohio consumers. That’s because more than 85 percent of Ohio’s electricity comes from coal-fired generation. Carbon-dioxide emissions per unit of output for coal-fired electric generation are twice that of equivalent natural gas generation. Consequently, Ohio electric suppliers will have to purchase nearly twice the quantity of emission allowances or offsets under the HR 2454 cap-and-trade program for their carbon-dioxide emissions. Because most of these allowances and offsets will be sold at prices set by auctions, higher costs will prevail and price volatility will become more the norm, rather than the exception, for electric rates.

The export of dollars from Ohio and other Midwest states is an especially punitive feature of HR 2454. The legislation grants free allowances to electric utilities with mostly noncarbon generation (hydroelectric or nuclear). These free allowances, in turn, will be sold to utilities that need them.

A government auction of emission allowances is the second glaring weakness of HR 2454. Based on conservative emission allowance prices, the Congressional Budget Office projects that auction proceeds to the federal treasury will total $846 billion by 2019. This is an energy tax on consumers and disproportionately on consumers in Ohio and other Midwest states who are dependent upon coal-fired electric generation.

For these reasons, the only responsible vote on HR 2454 is a “no” vote. Congress should go back to work on fashioning an affordable and achievable response to climate change.

Michael Sims

General manager

Butler Rural Electric

Cooperative Inc.

Share this article

ADD COMMENT

Comments feed

Say what you will Robert, but yet another cost will be passed down to the consumer through higer prices. Add this to other proposals and taxes that the Obama administration is putting through and you can all but guarantee that our economy will be forever weakened by these acts.

More Change
10:41 AM, 6/25/2009

REPORT ABUSE

More whining from energy producers whose greed got them into this mess in the first place. They should have been compelled to adopt stronger emission standards decades ago.

Robert
3:30 PM, 6/21/2009

REPORT ABUSE

This is the change you voted for only thing is who can afford it. All I can hope for under the socialists is spare change and this is just the start. Have you noticed the price at the pump lately. This could be avoided if we would only drill, so remember it is the people in charge right now who stopped just about all drilling in the US.
2010 is coming and it will be the start of the real change.

Jeff
5:42 AM, 6/21/2009

REPORT ABUSE

We welcome your comments. Please remember this is a public forum and behave appropriately. Your comments must conform to our visitor's agreement.