Updated: 11:47 p.m. Friday, April 12, 2013 | Posted: 6:05 p.m. Friday, April 12, 2013

Fairfield woman’s cause of death may never be known


Missing woman Katelyn Markham’s remains found photo
Katelyn Markham
Markham’s fiance ‘in shock,’ mother says photo
Staff photo by Nick Daggy
A vigil was held for Katelyn Markham in January 2012.
Police to begin piecing together Markham mystery again photo
Lopez, Steve (CMG-WestPalm)
The skeletal remains of Katelyn Markham were found Sunday, April 7, in Cedar Grove, Ind., is approximately 30 miles west of Fairfield.
Police to begin piecing together Markham mystery again photo
A teddy bear hangs at a makeshift memorial Thursday outside Katelyn Markham’s former home in Fairfield.
Police to begin piecing together Markham mystery again photo
Katelyn Markham

By Lauren Pack

Staff Writer


The long search is over for Katelyn Markham, but the quest for how she died is just beginning for multiple agencies in two states.

Markham’s skeletal remains were found Sunday morning in Cedar Grove, Ind., just 30 miles from her Fairfield home. She vanished from her Dorshire Drive residence in the summer of 2011. A missing person’s report was filed after Markham did not show up for work on Aug. 14 at David’s Bridal near Tri-County Mall.

Her remains, which are under the jurisdiction of the Franklin County Indiana Coroner’s Office, are at the Hamilton County Coroner’s Office, which is equipped for forensic examination. All information about procedures for examining the remains and determining the cause of death must come from Franklin County officials, according to the Hamilton County Coroner’s Office.

On Friday, Franklin County Indiana Coroner Wanda “Tink” Lee said she had no information about how the forensic examination would proceed, but added she may release information next week.

The reality is it could take sometime to determine how Markham died, if ever.

“It could take weeks,” said Sgt. Noel Houze of the Indiana State Police. He said it is possible a cause of death many never be known depending on the condition of the bones.

If a person is stabbed, for example, and no bones are hit, determining the cause of death from only the bones is virtually impossible, he said

Houze and Fairfield Police Chief Mike Dickey said detectives from both agencies are working together in the investigation.

Thursday evening, Katelyn’s father, Dave Markham, addressed a crowd of supporters at Fairfield West Baptist Church.

Hundreds have searched in the 20 months since Katelyn Markham went missing, hoping to find her or any clues that could lead to her whereabouts.

One of the locals, Diane Shuler, said she met a group of five other women who began searching together. On Monday, she went to visit the location where Markham was found.

“I could feel Katelyn, her spirit was there. All I could do is break down and cry. I was shaking,” said Shuler, who said the search group now plans to focus on finding Billy DiSilvestro, a Hamilton man missing since February 2011.

Shuler said the small search group met because of Katelyn and formed a life-long friendship.

“We met because of her,” Shuler said. They even took conceal and carry classes together to stay safe.

“One lady despised guns, but we felt if Katelyn would have had a carry and conceal, she would be alive,” Shuler said.


Hot topics