2012 senior class photos
2012 West Carrollton graduation
Home of the Week
Home > Blogs > Reality Bytes > Archives > 2010 > May > 26 > Entry
‘Another Idol’ upset: Dewyze beats Bowersox for Season 9 crown
Another upset!
Singer-songwriter Lee Dewyze, the 24-year-old paint salesman from Mt. Prospect, Ill., took home the “American Idol” Season 9 crown.
What??? I really thought Ohioan Crystal Bowersox had this one, especially after last night’s performances. Man …
Of course, Crystal deserved to win based on music talent alone. But we all know “American Idol” is about more than just who has the best voice.
If Crystal had to lose, I’m glad it was at least to the second best and certainly the most-improved. It’s hard not to be happy for Lee … this will completely change his life. You can tell how much this victory meant to him. He was the one contestant throughout the season who just seemed so happy and honored to be on stage. Not surprisingly, Lee was stunned and very emotional after the announcement.
Bowersox, 24, of Elliston near Toledo, the dreadlocked mom, known to many as Mama Sox, was the frontrunner from day one. Her captivating soulful, rock sound draws inspiration from some of music’s most powerful female artists including Janis Joplin, Bonnie Raitt and Melissa Etheridge.
But in the end, Lee’s a more commercial artist (he really does have a perfect radio voice), and that’s probably how he edged out Crystal. It would be interesting to see how the votes broke down and how close it was.
I’m sad for Ohio tonight. I was really hoping Ohio would get its first Idol, but I have no doubt Crystal will still have tremendous success. She really has an incredible talent.
I guess Lee needed this win more than Crystal … Crystal is a superstar with or without the “Idol” crown.
Besides, let’s just look at last season as proof. Who’s bigger: winner Kris Allen or runner-up Adam Lambert? Winner Ruben Studdard or runner-up Clay Aiken (well, maybe not now, but at least at the time)?
Here are some highlights from the remaining two hours:
So long Simon
Most of the show was devoted to Simon’s farewell.
I can’t imagine “American Idol” without Simon. Why even bother trying? He’s what made the show. Love him or hate him, he was always the voice of reason — and nine times out of 10 he was right on. Without him, here’s what we can expect week after week from the other judges: “It was just all right from” or “I wanted more” or “you didn’t connect with the meaning of the song.”
I think the only thing that can save “Idol” next season is a big gimmick, like maybe bringing back Idols past for a second chance in honor of Season 10. Imagine Sanjaya competing against Tim Urban for who gets to stick around longest without even deserving to be there at all.
I have a feeling Season 10 will be the last.
Paula Abdul returned to the show to help say goodbye to Simon with a roast. She assured America that the show will go on without Simon. The love child joke gives me the creeps almost as much as her hot pink dress. But it was nice to see her back even if she’s still crazy as can be.
A tribute video featuring the Idol judges, even Paula, sharing their favorite memories: From laughing in contestants’ faces, to slurping loudly during rehearsals, to abrupt cut-offs to auditions to classic Simon quotes such as “You’re not going to Hollywood, get out” to “It sounded like cats jumping off the Empire State building.”
Comedian Dane Cook performed a musical roast of Simon featuring his best quotes. It wasn’t really that funny, until some of the freaky people he insulted through the years came out on stage, including my favorite from Season 8, the most annoying Tatiana.
Another celebrity who wished him the best: Ricky Gervais (hmmm, possible token British guy replacement?)
Idol duets
Alice Cooper performed his classic hit “School’s Out” with Orianthe and the Top 12 Idols dressed as school children. That performance was slightly creepy, but that’s what we want from Alice Cooper anyway.
Siobhan Magnus and Aaron Kelly sang “How Deep is Your Love?” with the Bee Gees. I did not like the way Barry Gibb was looking at Siobhan.
Michael “Big Mike” Lynche sang “Takin’ it to the Streets” with Michael McDonald.
Ladies Lacey Brown, Didi Benami, Katie Stevens, Paige Miles, Siobhan Magnus and Crystal Bowersox sang a Christina Aguilera medley including “Beautiful” and “Fighter.” They were later joined by Christina herself (interesting hair and wardrobe choice by the way), there to plug her new album. It’s so nice to hear some real vocals, especially after hearing some of the early-season rejects like Lacey butcher notes on live TV.
The guys, Lee Dewyse, Casey James, Tim Urban, Michael Lynche, Aaron Kelly and Andrew Garcia sang Hall and Oates hits including “Maneater.” The duo performed “You Make My Dreams.”
Crystal Bowersox performed Alanis Morrisette’s “Ironic,” much to the delight of Toledo fans watching from the Huntington Center. Morrisette performed her breakout hit “You Oughta Know” with Crystal, a bit censored. That was the best duet of the night by a mile.
Casey James teamed up with Bret Michaels on “Every Rose Has It’s Thorn.” Shouldn’t that man still be home recovering from all of his health scares?
Lee Dewyze and Chicago (ha! how appropriate) performed a medley of hits, including “If You Leave Me,” also to the delight of Mt. Prospect fans.
The Top 10 performed “Again” with Janet Jackson. She then performed “Nothing” solo. She sounded eerily like Michael Jackson on that song. There were moments I was wondering if she was lip synching. Thankfully, no wardrobe malfunctions. One of the best moments of the show was Miss Janet’s “Nasty Boys” performance. Still love that song.
Crystal and Lee sang “With A Little Help From My Friends” with the legendary Joe Cocker. Another great moment.
This two-hour episode was so much better than “Idol Gives Back.” That was excruciating.
Idols from the past
Reigning American Idol Kris Allen performed “The Truth.” And Season 4 winner and country superstar Carrie Underwood performed “Undo It.”
American Idol winners Kelly Clarkson, Ruben Studdard, Fantasia Barrino, Carrie Underwood, Taylor Hicks (probably the worst Idol ever), Jordin Sparks and Kris Allen (the only one missing was David Cook) returned to perform together on stage — and were joined by tons of other contestants from throughout the last nine seasons. It’s nice to see Justin Guarini’s hair hasn’t changed a bit.
Really, there was no better sendoff for Simon than to see all the careers he launched sing together on one stage.
And last but not least …
Somehow we all knew he’d be back for an encore tonight. Gen. Larry Platt from the Atlanta auditions performed “Pants on the Ground,” which prompted a Facebook, Twitter and YouTube craze during the auditions, complete with a hip-hop dance crew. I preferred the original version … until William Hung joined him. Um, that was awesome!
Final thoughts on Season 9, my fellow “Idol” fans?
Tweet
Comments
By Squirrellygirl
June 1, 2010 8:49 AM | Link to this
to xxx: read your mean blog again. You sound jealous…are you jealous? Anyway, lighten won’t ya? Geez. What a horrible way to live your life attacking people you don’t even know. What a waste of energy.
By Squirrellygirl
June 1, 2010 8:27 AM | Link to this
to xxx: you’re a coward. Crystal should have won since she had the better voice and better performances. Lee even sang U2 song off key—it bothers me when someone does this consistently. Anyway imo Crystal should have been the winner hands down. I have to admit that this season was not as exciting as Season 7. That’s probably why the ratings were so low. Even the finale show wasn’t that great. I liked Crystal and Casey. Loved Casey and Brett Michaels on the finale—it was pretty good and I was glad to see Bret—he looked good. Hope he’s doing okay.
By chiliboots
May 27, 2010 7:43 PM | Link to this
All caps is offensive: knock it off, ‘Thirteen Craze’.
By chiliboots
May 27, 2010 7:38 PM | Link to this
Aguilara singing to old Tony Bennett is OK, tho?
By Jason
May 27, 2010 4:50 PM | Link to this
Really? Christina Aguilera sounded horrible, looked like she had a helmet on her head.
By xxx
May 27, 2010 2:11 PM | Link to this
So glad to see that Squirrelygirl left this place-unless she’s using another name. Guess that she figured out no one gave a crap about her “knowledge” or fact that she sang with “some guy” that used to sing with Ricky Nelson. BFD!
By agent
May 27, 2010 1:15 PM | Link to this
Both Lee and Crystal will have big careers, and I dare say that Crystal will probably do better (her tunes are out-selling Lee today on iTunes by quite a bit already).Carrie was fantastic and the best idol by far. Siobhan…get real. She’ll find success in something, but she won’t be “big” by any sense of the imagination.
By jp
May 27, 2010 1:11 PM | Link to this
…aging queens Paula and Janet wanting to steal the stage. Yuck. Oh come on, you will be there someday. They are both very talented, age has nothing to do with it. Lightin’ up and be kind.
By Don
May 27, 2010 10:49 AM | Link to this
“I did not like the way Barry Gibb was looking at Siobhan.” Barry Gibb has been married for 40 years and has 5 grown children, and by all accounts is a faithful husband and father. You are the one with the problem sweetie. Why DDN wastes bandwidth on you is beyond reason.
By liljay
May 27, 2010 10:15 AM | Link to this
The most disturbing parts (other than the winner) were aging queens Paula and Janet wanting to steal the stage. Yuck.
By Mr. Magoo
May 27, 2010 9:07 AM | Link to this
Michelle, thanks for the blogs this year. I think you were right: Crystal deserved to win, but I am not surprised that Lee did. What was up with Kelly Clarkson’s outfit and hair? I like her, but someone seriously needs to help her with her appearance. Finally, Paula bordered on tearful and bitter.
By THIRTEEN CRAZE
May 27, 2010 6:59 AM | Link to this
AGAIN THE WINNER IS VOTED IN BY TEENAGE GIRLS WHOSE HORMONES ARE GUIDING THEM TO VOTE FOR THE TEXTING OF THE HOTTEST BOY LEFT STANDING. MAYBE IT’S TIME TO LET PROFFESSIONALS CHOOSE THE BEST PERFORMER. MAYBE BOYS ARE JUST BETTER SINGERS….
By Ulysses
May 27, 2010 4:17 AM | Link to this
“Lets just see” the proof. Kelly, Carry and Jordin are deserving winners. U mock Sanjaya? Good, but Adam Lambert was just as annoying, and he cosistently proved he needed delirius(tinsel-town support who push 4 politics b4 honesty)hype and superficial stagings. The winners of season eight SHOULD have been Allison and Matt. No illusions required. Siobhan should have won this season.