2012 senior class photos
2012 West Carrollton graduation
Home of the Week
Home > Blogs > Reality Bytes > Archives > 2010 > February
February 2010
Did America get it right with “Idol” vote?
Did America get it right?
Well, not exactly — but close enough.
Dreams of winning the ninth “American Idol” title ended tonight for two ladies and two gentlemen — Janell Wheeler (“What About Love,” Heart), Ashley Rodriguez (“Happy” by Leona Lewis), Joe Munoz (“You and I Both,” Jason Mraz) and Tyler “70s guy” Grady (“American Woman”).
Obviously, America’s vote wasn’t based on this week’s performances alone or the judges’ commentary, or else Tim Urban, Haeley Vaughn, Lacey Brown and Alex Lambert should have been sent home. Some of their more memorable audition and Hollywood Week performances obviously carried them through to next week. If you recall, Tim Urban wasn’t even in the original Top 24, and had some real issues hitting notes during Wednesday night’s competition.
But, the four who did go home all had lackluster performances and probably wouldn’t have made it to the Top 12 anyway.
Did you get it right? Nope. Not even one. In our fun, completely unscientific poll, you told us that Haeley Vaughn, Lacey Brown, Tim Urban and Alex Lambert should have packed their bags. Hey, I think you got it right, at least.
Media Curves, a site that conducts communications research, polled 4,154 “American Idol” viewers on the Top 12 women and men. The survey predicted Rodriguez, Vaughn, Jermaine Sellers and Todrick Hall would go home. Hey, one out of four ain’t bad.
Next week, America will vote off two more ladies and two more guys, with episodes airing Tuesday (girls) and Wednesday (guys), followed by results on Thursday — all beginning at 8 p.m. EST.
Tell us what you think about the Top 20: who deserves and doesn’t deserve to be there?
TweetAre the “Idol” guys in it to win it?
I’m not sure if Simon’s right that a woman is destined to win Season 9 of “American Idol.” The guys could give the ladies a run for their money this season. Tonight’s performances from the Top 12 guys started off pretty rough, but at least five of the guys demonstrated they’re in it to win it.
When it comes to both genders, there are a handful of early standouts at this early stage of the competition. Here’s how the guys rated.
Who deserves to stay? Casey James, Aaron Kelly, Lee Dewyze, Andrew Garcia, Michael Lynche
Who should go? Tim Urban (not quite sure why he got a second chance) and Alex Lambert (the vocals weren’t strong enough to overpower the complete lack of confidence and stage presence).
Here’s a look at the Top 12 guys’ performances:
Todrick Hall
Song choice: “Since You’ve Been Gone” by Kelly Clarkson
Vocals: So-so
Judges comments: Ellen liked the fact he took a chance and put a unique twist on the song, but said the singing was not the greatest. Randy wasn’t a fan of Todrick’s completely different version of the song. Kara agreed with Randy, but loved that he took a risk. Simon said Todrick came across as a dancer who was trying to sing instead of a singer trying to dance. Simon then went on to say that Todrick “murdered” the original song and that the whole performance “verged on stupid.” Tell us how you really feel, Simon.
Overall impression: I didn’t care much for his version of the song, but he’s certainly a performer.
Grade: C+
Aaron Kelly
Song choice: “Here Comes Goodbye” by Rascal Flatts
Vocals: Strong
Judges comments: Simon said the performance was really good, but Aaron lacked confidence. Kara said she likes Aaron as a country artist. Randy said despite a few pitchy moments, it was a great performance. Ellen urged Aaron to gain confidence without losing himself.
Overall impression: The 16-year-old has a powerful voice and will probably have a strong fan base among the young girls, at least.
Grade: B
Jermaine Sellers
Song choice: “Get Here” by Oleta Adams
Vocals: Great vocal range, but a few bad notes
Judges comments: Ellen loved Jermaine’s look, but felt like the performance was a little over the top. Randy felt like it was an odd song choice and that Jermaine tried to make too much out of it. Kara said he showed range, but that range lacked meaning … it was just for the sake of showing range. Simon said this was the type of song you’d hear in a cocktail bar and that the performance was way over the top and that he totally blew his opportunity. Ellen and Kara disagreed.
Overall impression: Not the best Jermaine has to offer, but hopefully his past performances will carry him through. The talent is there; he just tried waaaaayyyy too hard tonight.
Grade: C
Tim Urban
Song choice: “Apologize” by OneRepublic
Vocals: Not so good, especially the falsetto notes
Judges comments: Simon congratulated Tim for coming back (he was a last-minute addition to the Top 24), but said the judges were right the first time when they didn’t put him through. Simon also said his voice isn’t good enough for this competition. Kara said the music “swallowed” him tonight, but that Tim is current and likable. Randy and Ellen agreed it was absolutely the wrong song choice, and Ellen also said that if he sticks around, he can’t just rest on his good looks to carry him through. Picking the right song is crucial.
Overall impression: This last-minute addition to the Top 24 proved tonight why he didn’t make the first cut. He really struggled to hit the notes. If America keeps Tim around for whatever reason, he has a lot to prove.
Grade: D
Joe Munoz
Song choice: “You and I Both” by Jason Mraz
Vocals: Good
Judges comments: Ellen said Joe had great stage presence. Randy said not the best song choice, but that he has a great voice. Kara liked the song choice, despite a few issues. Simon said it was an OK, safe, forgettable performance.
Overall impression: I like Joe’s voice, but I have to agree with the judges that the performance was pretty mediocre.
Grade: C+
Tyler Grady
Song choice: “American Woman” by The Guess Who
Vocals: So-so
Judges comments: Simon said it was memorable, but for the wrong reasons. Simon thought it was cliché and didn’t feel natural and that he needs to focus more on the vocals. Kara said the 70s bit may be too much, but he needs to bring it into this decade. Randy said it was style over substance. Ellen felt that Tyler was going through all the motions without the charisma behind it. Randy said be original.
Overall impression: I wasn’t wowed by any means. It was another so-so performance. The song didn’t really show what he’s capable vocally. I don’t think it was a strong enough first-impression with the voters.
Grade: C
Lee Dewyze
Song choice: “Chasing Cars” by Snow Patrol, playing guitar
Vocals: Pretty good, despite a few bad notes
Judges comments: Ellen thought it was a good song choice, despite a few screamy moments, but that he should definitely stay. Randy didn’t like the song choice for Lee’s rock sound and suggested Kings of Leon would have been a better fit. Kara said the song had a small range that forced Lee to make some changes to the song that didn’t really work. Simon disagreed and thought it was the best performance of the night so far (Lee was the seventh to perform). Simon said Lee is a naturally good singer and predicted he will do well in the competition.
Overall impression: I really like Lee. We didn’t see much of him during the earlier rounds of the competition, and I’d like to see him return. A dark horse, perhaps?
Grade: B
John Park
Song choice: “God Bless the Child” by Billie Holiday
Vocals: Very strong
Judges comments: Simon criticized the song choice, saying that it was a pointless performance that left him flat. Kara agreed and said the performance was indulgent. Randy commended his voice, but said that the song didn’t work. Ellen, too, questioned the song choice, but liked the performance.
Overall impression: I absolutely love John’s voice, and he was someone who stood out for me during the early auditions. But I would like to see John sing something a bit more modern. It’s hard to envision what kind of artist John would be, but I think he certainly deserves another shot based on his voice alone.
Grade: B-
Michael Lynche
Song choice: “This Love” by Maroon 5 with guitar
Vocals: Good
Judges comments: Ellen said Michael is infectious … he has a great personality that really comes across on stage. Randy said he likes Michael’s energy and persona. Kara said there were good things about the performance but that it wasn’t outrageously great, and that Big Mike should challenge himself more. Simon said it was a vague, jazzy version, but that he needs to nail the song and get people to listen as an artist.
Overall impression: Michael is just really likable. This performance didn’t showcase a lot of vocal skill, but it was fun and Michael was having fun. I would like to hear more of his vocal range. Don’t think that will be a problem given some of the other performances of the night.
Grade: B
Alex Lambert
Song choice: “What a Wonderful World” by James Morrison
Vocals: So-so; a couple notes made me cringe
Judges comments: Simon said the performance was incredibly uncomfortable. Kara said Alex needed a hug. Despite the awkward performance, the vocal talent is there. Randy said Alex has the voice, but that pulling it together is the problem. Ellen complimented the mullet and the voice.
Overall impression: Maybe I’m comparing Alex Lambert to Adam Lambert, but that performance just didn’t work. Despite a decent voice, Alex completely lacked confidence, and it was just really awkward. I’m so happy Ellen mentioned the mullet. It was borderline mullet and I couldn’t help but stare at it throughout the performance wondering if it truly qualified as a mullet.
Grade: D+
Casey James
Song choice: “Heaven” by Bryan Adams with guitar
Vocals: Excellent
Judges comments: The lovestruck Kara couldn’t speak. Ellen said it didn’t matter, she’ll get votes like crazy. Randy said it was a great song choice. When Kara pulled herself together, she said he is eye candy and ear candy. Simon said he chose the right song and the performance was honest and sincere and his personal best.
Overall impression: Casey has star power. Great voice. May be the next Bo Bice, but only way, way hotter.
Grade: A-
Andrew Garcia
Song choice: “Sugar We’re Going Down” by Fallout Boy with guitar
Vocals: Solid
Judges comments: Simon said he was looking forward to Andrew’s performance the most, and that it was a letdown and too serious. Kara said it was a strange rendition of that song. Randy and Ellen think his Hollywood Week performance of “Straight Up” will carry him through.
Overall impression: I’ve been a big Andrew fan from the beginning. Tonight’s performance wasn’t his personal best (“Straight Up” was amazing), but he’s the kind of guy you want to see win, and I love how he puts his own stamp on every song.
Grade: B+
Now it’s your turn: What did you think of tonight’s performances? Who should stay and who should go?
Did the ladies outshine the gentlemen this week (or vice versa)?
TweetDo you agree with Simon? Rate the Top 12 ladies
Simon Cowell predicts a female will win “American Idol” this year. The ladies were out to prove him right tonight during the first live episode.
During the next three weeks, the ladies and gentlemen will perform on separate nights. Each week, two guys and two girls will go home based on America’s vote until all that remains is the Top 12.
Who got it mostly right tonight? Crystal Bowersox, Katelyn Epperly, Katie Scott, Michelle Delamor
Who should go home based on tonight’s performance? Lacey Brown, Haeley Vaughn. But I have to say Haeley’s past performances could carry her through, which could mean farewell to Ashley Rodriguez or Janell Wheeler.
Here’s tonight’s scorecard:
Paige Miles
Song choice: “It’s All Right Now” by Free
Vocals: Strong
Judges comments: Simon said she has the best voice out of all the girls, but her performance was “wedding singer”-ish. Kara loved her choice of a rock song. Randy didn’t like the song choice, but still thought she showed her talent. Ellen thought it was an overall good performance, especially being the first of the first live night.
Overall impression: A very good singer, but not the best song choice. This is the most we’ve seen of Paige so far, and I think she’ll be back based on tonight’s performance.
Grade: B-
Ashley Rodriguez
Song choice: “Happy” by Leona Lewis
Vocals: Average
Judges comments: The judges agreed the song was probably too big for Ashley … once again another case of choosing a song by an artist that is simply too big to take on. Simon took it a step further and said it was “clumsy” and lacked originality.
Overall impression: Ashley’s stage presence and overall marketability could save her this week.
Grade: C
Janell Wheeler
Song choice: “What About Love?” by Heart
Vocals: So-so. A little screechy at times.
Judges comments: The judges were mixed on this one. Randy, Simon and Kara didn’t like the song choice, but Ellen did.
Overall impression: A Heart song can make or break you. Think back to Carrie Underwood and Allison Iraheta’s versions of “Alone.” Janell’s performance cannot compare. But I think her audition and Hollywood Week performances, as well as her general likability, will carry her through this time.
Grade: C+
Lilly Scott
Song choice: “Fixing a Hole” by The Beatles, with guitar
Vocals: Good, very distinct voice
Judges comments: Ellen loved it. Simon commended her for choosing a song that fit her, but said he wasn’t seeing any “star power” yet. Kara said her performance came from the heart and that she sensed her comfort on stage.
Overall impression: Lilly is an indie artist and gave a very genuine, heartfelt performance … I guess it will all come down to whether Lilly’s sound fits with this competition.
Grade: B
Katelyn Epperly
Song choice: “Oh! Darling” by The Beatles
Vocals: Strong, with a lot of range and personality
Judges comments: Simon, despite a few screechy moments, thought it was a brave performance and a good song choice. “I like you a lot,” he said. Kara said she could tell Katelyn has been singing all her life and really knows her voice and how to use it well. Randy also acknowledged she really knows her vocals. Ellen questioned if it was too much.
Overall impression: Katelyn’s definitely a performer with a strong voice to back it up. She’ll stick around for awhile. And love the hair.
Grade: B+
Haeley Vaughn
Song choice: “I Wanna Hold Your Hand” by The Beatles, with guitar
Vocals: So-so … some great and not-so-great moments. To borrow a classic Randy line, it was a little “pitchy.”
Judges comments: The judges were torn on this one. Kara criticized her technical delivery. Randy complimented her unpredictability but questioned her delivery on the high notes. Ellen said she really shines on stage. Simon said it “verged on terrible” and that she smiled too much.
Overall impression: Kind of a cheesy performance. She is young and was trying to have fun, but it was still a bit over the top for me. I was hoping for more from Haeley. At least she put her own spin on the classic song. When she auditioned, she said she wanted to be a country artist, and that made her stand out. But for some reason she seems to be searching for her identity on stage when she had it all along.
Grade: C-
Lacey Brown
Song choice: “Landslide” by Fleetwood Mac
Vocals: Not good on this song at least
Judges comments: Randy said it was terrible, pitchy and not right for her voice. Ellen said she really likes Lacey, but that performance didn’t work. Simon said it was indulgent and depressing — and boring. Kara said Lacey usually hits notes with ease, but she struggled this time because of the song choice.
Overall impression: Lacey has the potential to be good, but I don’t think she did enough tonight to stick around to prove it.
Grade: C-
Michelle Delamor
Song choice: “Fallin’” by Alicia Keys
Vocals: Good, but it’s hard to compete with Alicia Keys.
Judges comments: Ellen thought it was fantastic, but a safe choice. Simon said she did well and was close to the original, but not as good. He said there was no “wow” moment and that it wasn’t different. Kara said there were a few technical issues with the performance and that she needs some more believability. Randy said it was a tough song to do, but she did pretty well. Randy encouraged her to take some risks.
Overall impression: Michelle could be a real contender in this competition if she can find her identity. Strong voice and very marketable. She’s the overall package.
Grade: B
Didi Benami
Song choice: “The Way I am” by Ingrid Michaelson
Vocals: Good. Didi has a folksy-indie vibe.
Judges comments: Simon said she’s a good singer, and everyone is trying to sound like the same artist. He said he’s missing a spark, but that he likes her. Kara said the song choice was good and that she showed her creative side by taking some risks. Randy said Didi was missing the star factor. Ellen said she has a great look and voice, but that the first impression was too low-key.
Overall impression: Despite the judges’ criticisms, I do think Didi knows who she is and has made a strong impression so far. Didi is one of those people you truly want to see go far.
Grade: B
Siobhan Magnus
Song choice: “Wicked Game” by Chris Isaak
Vocals: Started off a little rough and borderline creepy, but got much better quickly
Judges comments: Kara said she kinda liked it despite the fact it was a little nasaly and that Siobhan made a connection with people. Randy said this song didn’t showcase her range of vocal talent. Ellen loved the mystery and her stage presence. Simon said she’s a “funny little thing” but that he liked it despite it being a very dark song.
Overall impression: I’m intrigued with Siobhan. I didn’t love this performance, but there’s something about her. Hope she sticks around.
Grade: B
Crystal Bowersox
Song choice: “Hand in My Pocket” by Alanis Morissette with guitar and harmonica.
Vocals: Excellent. I got goosebumps
Judges comments: Randy said she’s one of his favorites for her originality and the honesty even if not the best song choice for her. Ellen said she adds “something fresh” to the show. Simon said Crystal needs to make a song her own by doing something no one else has done, but that she’s refreshing and will do well. Kara said she has the ability to take people on a journey, but didn’t do that tonight.
Overall impression: I agree this didn’t show her star quality as much as some of her earlier performances, but she is great. I love her voice and her stage presence. Definitely the best of the night. O-H-I-O!
Grade: A-
Katie Stevens
Song choice: “Feeling Good” by Michael Buble
Vocals: What a big voice for such a young girl! Excellent, but off key at times.
Judges comments: The judges were unanimous in this one - the song was too old for Katie and that she needs to be more current. Nonetheless, she has some real talent.
Overall impression: Despite the judges’ criticism, I think Katie showed her potential and real vocal skills. Katie will do very well in this competition. She’s adorable, has great stage presence and a big voice.
Grade: B+
Your turn: Who should stay? Who should go?
Up next: The guys perform in a two-hour episode on Wednesday at 8 p.m. EST on Fox. The results show will air Thursday.
TweetThe real competition kicks off tonight
Before tonight and Wednesday’s two-hour episodes airing at 8 p.m. EST on Fox, brush up on your Top 24. Tonight, the top 12 ladies will perform and Wednesday, the top 12 guys will perform.
On Thursday, two girls and two guys will be sent home after America votes.
And attention all Allison Iraheta fans from Season 8. Iraheta, who was the last girl standing last season, will perform her new single, “Scars” on the first American Idol results show of the season Thursday, Feb. 25 8/7c on FOX. And of course, American Idol Season 8 winner Kris Allen will perform.
TweetWhat happened to Chris Golightly?
Anyone who was watching Wednesday’s Top 24 revealing “ceremonies” on “American Idol” this week probably noticed something odd.
In revealing the Top 12 guys, something just didn’t add up. During the episode, we saw 12 females and 11 males receive word from the judges they made it. Toward the very end of the show, contestant Chris Golightly (curly hair, sort of like Justin Guarini’s from Season One) was seen among the 24 semifinalists on stage with host Ryan Seacrest. But during the preview for next week’s episodes featuring each contestant individually, Golightly was not mentioned and Tim Urban was featured (where did he come from?)
Basically, Golightly didn’t disclose that he’d had a music contract, so he was released from the show. Tim Urban was chosen as his replacement.
TweetTop 24 revealed: Now it’s America’s turn to choose
A few surprises, but certainly no shockers.
Here’s the official list of who made the Top 24 of “American Idol” Season 9. Now it’s down to 12 guys and 12 girls, who will sing their hearts out some more, this time to earn America’s vote.
By the way,“Idol” managed to drag out the big reveal over three hours and two nights (was that really necessary?), but finally …
The girls
Didi Benami, the 23-year-old waitress from Hollywood who lost her best friend and auditioned in her memory, and particularly impressed with a performance of a Kara DioGuardi song earlier during Hollywood Week. Didi is very likable and has a vulnerable quality that will probably win her a lot of votes.
Katelyn Epperly, 19, of West Des Moines, Iowa. Katelyn, who has really big hair and an equally big voice, openly discussed during her original audition the challenges she’s facing as her parents divorce.
Janell Wheeler, 24, of Tampa, Fla. Janell is a wine sales rep from Orlando who just happens to have a great voice, good looks and charm.
Lacey Brown, 24, of Amarillo, Texas. Lacey returned from last year’s Top 50. Although she didn’t get much air time during Hollywood Week, she was a standout during the earlier auditions.
Ashley Rodriguez, 22, of Chelsea, Mass. She’s absolutely gorgeous and talented. That’s a winning combination in this industry.
Crystal Bowersox, 24, of Elliston, Ohio. This dreadlocked hippie chick and mom from the Toledo/Sandusky area has a captivating voice and charm. If she would have been cut, it would have been an injustice. And I’m not just saying that because she’s from the Buckeye State. She could be a real contender if America is willing to take a chance on someone who doesn’t quite fit the typical “Idol” mold.
Katie Stevens, 17, of Middlebury, Conn., who wants to make her Grandma with Alzheimers proud. I think she has succeeded in that already, and I bet she goes pretty far in this competition.
Lilly Scott, 20, of Littleton, Colo. Lilly is the unique jazz artist with silverish, blond hair who sort of reminds me of actress Zoey Deschanel
Paige Miles, 24, of Cypress, Texas. I’m honestly not sure where she came from and don’t remember her from the auditions. I guess she, too, is one of those contestants who has gotten little to no air time so far.
Siobhan Magnus, 19, of Barnstable, Mass., who is a singer in a band hoping to make a name for herself.
Michelle Delamor, 22, of Miami, was another one who didn’t get a huge amount of air time, but showed she deserved a spot in the top, especially with her performance during group week in Hollywood. Let’s see how she sounds in comparison to the remaining Top 12 ladies.
Haeley Vaughn, 16, of Fort Collins, Colo. Haeley is the very likable aspiring African-American country star. But, like the judges said, she was inconsistent and at times “annoying.” Hope she finds her niche and sticks to it. She could be an interesting one to watch this season.
The guys
Michael Lynche or “Big Mike” —, 26, of Astoria, N.Y., who missed the birth of his baby girl for his shot at stardom. Guess it was all worth it, huh? Let’s just hope all the buzz in cyberspace about some controversy that keeps him off stage is just rumor. Mike’s lovable personality and vocal talents (plus the fact that’s he’s just massive) could take him to the top of this competition, or close to it.
Casey James, 27, of Fort Worth, Texas. Cases is the motorcycle accident victim who overcame doctors’ odds and who won over Kara (and guest judge Victoria Beckham) in early auditions by taking his shirt off. He sort of has that male model look about him, which can’t hurt his chances. Although he seemed like a joke during the early auditions, he really proved himself as a musician with some great performances during Hollywood Week.
Aaron Kelly, a 16-year-old high school student from Sonestown, Penn., who overcame a tough childhood and was raised by his aunt. Aaron had many ups and downs during Hollywood Week, so let’s see if he can hold up under the pressure of performing live on TV.
Lee Dewyze, 23, of Mount Prospect, Ill. Lee has a big powerful voice but didn’t always demonstrate confidence on stage. Lee learned from the judges he was a last-minute addition to the Top 12 guys. Lee was one of those contestants who didn’t get a lot of air time during the earlier audition rounds, so it will be interesting to see how he fares with TV viewers. Maybe he’ll pull a Kris Allen on America. Who knows.
Todrick Hall, 24, of Arlington, Texas. Todrick is a dancer who has a natural singing ability and who performed on Broadway with past Idol winner Fantasia. He’s definitely an entertainer.
Tyler Grady, 20, of Nazareth, Penn. Tyler is the 70s style drummer turned frontman with, well, interesting hair. He looks and dresses like someone straight out of the 70s.
Alex Lambert, 19, of North Richland Hills, Texas. He didn’t leave a strong impression so far, but maybe we’re all automatically comparing him with Adam Lambert because the names are so similar.
Joe Munoz, 20, Huntington Park, Calif. Another who didn’t get much face time.
Jermaine Sellers, 26, of Joliet, Ill. His performance of “What if God Was One of Us?” stood out during the early auditions, proving he’s much more than a church singer.
Tim Urban, 20, of Duncanville, Texas. Rumor has it Tim was a last-minute replacement for Chris Golightly (the foster child who made quite an impression during the Los Angeles auditions) who ended up not making the Top 24 due to a contract issue). Anyone who was playing close attention would have noticed that Tim was not listed in the Top 12 during the show, but oddly ended up in the montage of bad dancing at the end of the episode.
John Park, 21, Evanston, Ill., a member of a popular co-ed a cappella group at Northwestern University
Andrew Garcia, 24, of Moreno Valley, Calif. Andrew will make a name for himself this season and has a shot at making it far by putting his stamp on famous music, much in the way he performed an acoustic version of former judge Paula Abdul’s “Straight Up.” He’s been one of my favorites from the beginning. Let’s see if he continues to deliver.
Who’s missing?
No shockers, really. There are a couple in the Top 24 who haven’t gotten much TV time, so it will be interesting to see how that affects how long they stick around and if they were really better than some of the people who we came to really like that didn’t make the final cut such as …
Angela Martin, the third time wasn’t the charm for Angela. The talent this season was fierce, but boy does this lady deserve a break. She lost her father, spent time in jail for a traffic violation and is raising a child with medical problems. I was impressed with the way judge Kara gently delivered the disappointing news. It was the only long-drawn out delivery (good or bad) that seemed genuine.
Thaddeus Johnson, 16, who was one who really stood out during the auditions, but didn’t make it. That broke my heart, actually. How tough all of this must be for a teen to go through.
Also, Tori Kelly. Let’s hope she comes back next year. She’s really good, very marketable and has a really strong stage presence.
And two who were cut during yesterday’s show that I really liked — Jermaine Purifoy and Hope Johnson.
Now it’s your turn: did the judges pick the right 24? What did they get right and what did they get wrong?
Up next: Next Tuesday, the top 12 ladies take the stage live, followed by the guys on Wednesday.
TweetSneak peek at “American Idol” Season 9 Top 24
Here they are … seven of the Top 24 from “American Idol” Season 9. After a seven-city national search and a tear-filled, tension-filled Hollywood Week with 181 Idol hopefuls, here’s who have made it past the judges so far and who will work to earn America’s vote.
The remaining 17 will be revealed Wednesday night, and the teasers include a “shocking elimination.” In the end, 12 males and 12 females will advance and get the chance to win over America.
The girls
1. Didi Benami, who lost her best friend and auditioned in her memory, and particularly impressed judges with a performance of a Kara DioGuardi song earlier during Hollywood Week.
2. Katelyn Epperly,a young girl with really big hair and a really big voice
The guys
1. Michael Lynche or “Big Mike” — who missed the birth of his baby girl for his shot at stardom. Guess it was all worth it, huh?
2. Casey James, the motorcycle accident victim who won over Kara (and guest judge Victoria Beckham) in early auditions by taking his shirt off. He sort of has that male model look about him
3. Aaron Kelly, a 16-year-old high school student who overcome a tough childhood and was raised by his aunt, but who had many ups and downs during Hollywood Week.
4. Lee Dewyze, who has a big powerful voice but didn’t always demonstrate confidence on stage. Lee learned from the judges he was a last-minute addition to the Top 12 guys. Lee was one of those contestants who didn’t get a lot of air time during the earlier audition rounds, so it will be interesting to see how he fares with TV viewers.
5. Todrick Hall, the dancer who has a natural singing ability and who performed on Broadway with past Idol winner Fantasia.
Who are your early favorites? Anyone on this list who you think doesn’t deserve a Top 24 spot? Did any of your favorites go home too soon?
Here’s who would round out my Top 24 list …
Girls: Crystal Bowersox, Ashley Rodriguez, Haeley Vaughn, Katie Stevens, Siobhan Magnus, Janell Wheeler, Lilly Scott, Katie Stevens, Lacey Brown, Michelle Delamor
Guys: Andrew Garcia, Jermaine Sellers, Tyler Grady, John Park, Jose Munoz, JB Ahfua, Thaddeus Johnson
Who I was sad to see go: Jermaine Purifoy, one of my faves during the audition rounds but who blew it with his “Brick House” audition during Hollywood Week. Hope Johnson, although she didn’t stand out during Hollywood Week, I was hoping for her Cinderella story to come true. The good news for Hope is there’s always hope for next year.
Not so sad to see go: Jessica Furney, the Lisa-Loeb lookalike who begged the judges to give her another chance. It was really pathetic and annoying. Mary Powers, despite loving her during the early auditions, I found her arrogance and bossiness really annoying during Hollywood Week. She’s good, but not that good.
TweetGetting closer to the “American Idol” Top 24
The claws came out tonight on “American Idol.”
Excitement and anticipation turned into power struggles, tears, finger-pointing, fatigue and frustration. And I’m not talking about the judges (at least for now … we’ll see how the rest of the season goes).
Ninety-six contestants made it to group night tonight on “American Idol,” and there was plenty of drama.
But there was also plenty of star power.
In the end, 71 made it through to the final Hollywood Week round, which airs next Tuesday, Feb. 16, at 8 p.m. on FOX. The Top 24 (12 males, 12 females) will be revealed the following night.
Here are some of the highlights from Hollywood Week, night two:
Who shined: Three seemed to be the lucky number. The trios of Janell Wheeler, Jermain Purifoy and Casey James; Andrew Garcia, Katie Stevens and J.B. Ahfua; and Ashley Rodriguez, Michelle Delamore and Charity Vance all impressed the judges.
In other groups, only a few stood out from the rest. This held true for Tim Urban and Mike Lynche, who talked his wife through the birth of their first child, a girl, over the phone literally minutes before he auditioned. Thankfully, for his sake, he made it through to the next round (imagine being sent home right after missing the birth of your first child!)
This also was the case for the drama group led by Mary “Power Trip” Powers. The judges looked past the awful performance and let rocker Powers, Texas girl Hope Johnson and the lone male of the group through.
Among the 25 who went home: Jack Black/Jack Osbourne/Michael Moore hybrid Mark Labriola. Former jailbird Matt Lawrence, drama queen Amanda Shechtman and the very likable Seth Rollins, the father of an autistic boy.
Who makes my top 24 so far (based on tonight’s and past performances from some who didn’t get much air time tonight): Andrew Garcia, Ashley Rodriguez, Ohio’s Crystal Bowersox, Didi Benami, Katie Stevens, Janell Wheeler, Casey James, Jermaine Purifoy, Lilly Scott and Haeley Vaughn. Katelyn Epperly and Lacey Brown were among my favorites from the early audition rounds, but haven’t seen much of them at all during Hollywood Week.
Who do you want to see make it to the final 24?
TweetHello Ellen, Hello Hollywood: Did you spot the next “Idol”?
Let the competition begin.
After a seven-city national search, 181 people hoping to be named the ninth “American Idol” performed on stage at Hollywood’s Kodak Theatre hoping to show the panel of four judges why they deserve a spot in the Top 24.
And the moment fans have been waiting for … Ellen DeGeneres made her “Idol” debut during the first Hollywood Week episode (Feb. 9).
She certainly isn’t stepping in to be the “nice judge” like her predecessor. Ellen’s blunt yet humorous commentary really complements Simon’s brutal honesty. For example, she told the really arrogant Atlanta contestant Skiiboski that he was scary and he appeared to be stalking them, and certainly wasn’t afraid to tell people their performance pretty much sucked.
Already, I have to wonder if Kara and Randy will get a word in this season?
In the end, it will be down to 12 guys and 12 girls — and looking at the crop of multi-talented musicians who shined tonight, the judges could face some tough choices this season. Here’s a look at who survived the first cut (and who didn’t).
In: The very genuine 17-year-old Katie Stevens (the sweet girl whose story includes a grandma battling Alzheimers), worship pastor Tasha Leighton, Charity Vance, Ashley Rodriguez, Todrick Hall and guitarist Tim Urban
In and well on their way to the Top 24: Andrew Garcia took a huge risk and sang an acoustic “Straight Up” by former Idol judge Paula Abdul. Um, way better than the original. (Can you imagine how Paula would have reacted). Janell Wheeler (pretty blonde guitarist with a great stage presence). Guitarist Haeley Vaughn (the aspiring black pop-country singer). 28-year-old mama Rocker Mary Powers (who sounds a lot like Pink). Lilly Scott, the singing, guitar-playing sandwich-maker. Michael Lynch, whose wife was in labor with their first child while he auditioned in hopes of pursuing his dream. Casey James, the hottie blues guitarist who partially stripped down for Kara and Posh Spice during the audition rounds. Waitress Didi Benami, who sang a Kara DioGuardi (sucking up perhaps? ). Single mom and hippie chick Crystal Bowersox of Elliston, Ohio, who brought the crowd to its feet while belting out “Natural Woman.” (O-H-I-O)
Out: Our friend Antonio “Skiiboski” Wheeler (but not without a fight), small-town country girl Vanessa Wolfe (at least she got to ride on an “aero-plane” to Hollywood), pant-splitter Cornelius Edwards, beat boxer Jay Stone, cancer survivor Justin Williams, Barney girl Erica Rhodes, annoying Jersey sisters Amanda and Bernadette Desimone, Paige DeChausse (who shined during auditions), the big sister to some special-needs children Maddy Curtis, the super-energetic Maegan Wright, nice Italian boy Amedeo Dirocco and unfortunately Columbus guy Bosa Mora, who Randy said we’ll see performing soon at the “Holiday Inn Columbus.”
At least Ohio girl Crystal should be a real contender in this competition.
And of course, there were many who got zero face time on TV, but you can check out photos and video of them at www.americanidol.com.
What do you think? Did anyone spot the next “American Idol”?
TweetSome of the best and brightest from the “Idol” auditions
While we wait to see who will stand out from the 181 contestants who made it to Hollywood Week, let’s take a look back at some of the highlights of the audition rounds from Boston to Denver.
The best:
Tonight (Feb. 3), “Idol” showcased some of the best and brightest from the audition rounds. Here are some people to watch for during Hollywood week who we hadn’t seen in the earlier episodes this season.
The Lisa Loeb lookalike Jessica Furney, who scored points by singing a song co-penned by judge Simon Cowell himself.
Drama queen Amanda Shectman, who is a great singer (and actress) … I loved the Britney impression before her audition more than the audition itself. Hard to believe this girl has a theater background.
Crystal Bowersox, a hippie chick from Ohio who carries around a guitar like a blankie.
Season 8 Top 50 contestant Lacey Brown, who made the judges feel warm and fuzzy inside with her performance of “Somewhere Over the Rainbow.”
Super talented teens Rachel Hubbard, Thaddeus Johnson and Genesis Moore.
Dad-to-be and personal trainer Michael Lynche, with a voice as big as his guns, won over the judges with “Unchained Melody.”
Inspirational stories, strong voices:
A winning combination when it comes to “Idol,” no doubt.
Didi Benami, who sang “Hey Jude” in honor of her late best friend, her biggest fan.
Aaron Kelly whose song choice, “The Climb” by Miley Cyrus, was very fitting given his challenges early in life.
Hope Johnson, who hoped to sing her way to a better life with “I Hope You Dance”
The headscratchers:
Stephanie Fisher, whose “Fever” audition left the judges cold. At least she got to trade fashion tips with her fashion Icon Victoria Beckham.
The 6-foot-8 swimmer Adrian “Blondzilla” Chandtchi, aka “the beautiful manflower,” had a really tiny voice that didn’t at all match his body.
Goth chick Kimberly Bishop, who sang a frighteningly weird version of Katy Perry’s “I Kissed A Girl.” Thankfully, Perry wasn’t at the judge’s table to see that one.
Some favorites from the last couple weeks:
Aspiring black pop-country singer Haeley Vaughn, who auditioned in Denver to Carrie Underwood’s “Don’t Even Know His Last Name.” Her tales of personal tragedy can only help her win the hearts of America.
Leukemia survivor Christian Spear, 16, who sang “All I Can Do is Cry” by Etta James during the Texas auditions.
Orlando contestant 25-year-old Matt Lawrence, whose performance of “Trouble” was pretty appropriate considering he spent four years in jail after he robbed a bank with a BB-gun while a teenager.
Jermaine Purlfoy, who auditioned while in college for Season 7, and impressed the judges in Orlando with a little Tony Bennett.
Denver contestant Casey James, the motorcycle accident victim who beat the odds and was able to play the guitar again — and who Kara and Victoria asked to remove his shirt and let his hair down.
Andrew Garcia, a father seeking a better life for his son.
The “complete package” Ashley Rodriguez, who sang a sultry version of “If I Ain’t Got You” by Alicia Keyes during the Boston auditions.
Bluesy 21-year-old Paige Dechausee of Illinois, whose asthma nearly took her life at age 15.
Best audition:
The award for most memorable audition goes to none other than Gen. Larry Platt himself. His original song “Pants on the Ground” has become an instant hit in cyberspace and is committed to memories from here to Texas. No golden ticket, but I’m sure Larry isn’t complaining with all his newfound fame.
Up next:
Hollywood Week kicks off next Tuesday, Feb. 9, (when new judge Ellen DeGeneres will make her official “American Idol” debut.
Now it’s your turn:
Have any contestants made a real impression on you so far this season? Anyone you hope to see in the Top 24? Early predictions?
TweetMove over bikini girl … you’ve got some competition
Move over bikini girl. Make way for bikini boy.
Yep. Tonight on “American Idol,” this guy stooped pretty low to get his 15 minutes of fame.
The judges had to walk out in disgust when Ty Hemmelgarn strutted in the Denver audition room wearing a two-piece.
“Achy Breaky Heart” in a bikini was more than they could stomach. Let’s just be glad he wasn’t rockin’ a mullet Billy Ray style.
Does anyone else predict a bikini duet in the finals?
Now onto the rest …
Victoria “Posh Spice” Beckham was back at the judges’ table with Randy, Simon and Kara this week during Denver auditions on Tuesday, Feb. 2. Her fashion, not surprisingly, was more memorable than her commentary. She wore a bright purple awards-ceremony worthy dress on day one and then a big bun on top of her head on day two. Well, at least she looked good.
Now onto the contestants …
Superstar potential: Triumph over adversity alert! A premature baby called a miracle and who later lost her father shared her dreams of becoming a black pop-country singer. Haeley Vaughn, who auditioned to Carrie Underwood’s “Don’t Even Know His Last Name,” makes my Top 12 prediction list because she’s so unique and has a really likable personality.
The very emotional live karaoke host and covers band member Danielle Hayes, who sang “The Only One” by Melissa Etheridge.
Tori Kelly, the beautiful 16-year-old, who sang John Mayer. Simon called her voice annoying, but the others loved her. I’m not sure what planet Simon was on during that audition. She was really good, and so darn adorable.
Nicci Nix, who has a really high-pitched speaking voice (sort of like Jennifer Tilly’s, actually), but a surprising lovely singing voice. Her 14-hour flight from Florence paid off. Love the superstar name, by the way.
Not too shabby: Now this one threw me off. Mark Labriola, the Jack Black (and sort of Jack Osbourne) lookalike who shared his love for cheese and tales of his life on the run, sang “Tempted” surprisingly well. He just looked like someone who would, well, totally suck. It’s true. When it comes to “Idol” auditions, you can usually tell if the person will be good or bad at first sight.
Kimberly Kerbow, the single mom who managed to criticize Simon’s hair in song.
Casey James, the motorcycle accident victim who beat the odds and was able to play the guitar again. Casey only impressed half the judges with his voice … but his good looks saved him. At the ladies’ request, he pulled his hair down from a ponytail and took off his shirt. In a competition like this, looks do matter. But that was a bit ridiculous. I felt sorry for the poor guy.
Shame of a nation: Mario Galvan, the trenchcoat-wearing nicotine addiction counselor, didn’t get a get out of jail free card with his lackluster “Jailhouse Rock” performance.
Austin Paul, the incredibly arrogant college music student and football player, who wasn’t horrible, but not good either. He should really stick to football.
The self-proclaimed world’s best singer, aka the male Mary J. Blige Kenny Everett couldn’t live up to his claims of grandeur with his screeching audition. Kenny was so shocked that the four judges couldn’t see his true talent.
The worst? I appreciated the montage of Vegas singers, cat killers and horrible dancers. But I’ve gotta go with bikini boy.
Stay tuned for the final audition round to air Wednesday, Feb. 3 at 8 p.m. (EST) on Fox.
Tweet
