Home > Blogs > Chatterbox > Archives > 2010 > January > 11 > Entry
Will Ellen DeGeneres be a good “American Idol” judge?
Will Ellen DeGeneres be a good “American Idol” judge?
MICHAEL ROWAN, West Carrollton: “Yes and no. Yes, because she’ll be incredibly entertaining because of her sense of humor. Her and Simon together will be a blast. No, because I don’t think she’s qualified whatsoever to be a judge for ‘American Idol.’ She has no vocal ability, no musical talent; she can’t even dance.”
JOANIE TOROK, Springboro: “Sure. I think she’ll really be entertaining. The judges have to be entertaining.”
LUDESTA GRIFFIN, Huber Heights: “I would say yes and no. She doesn’t have much experience with recording artists and judging people’s performances. On the other hand, she doesn’t criticize people too hard. She’s a comedian, so that should make the show a little better. But at least Paula (Abdul) had dancing and video performance experience.”
DANIELLE BIELLER, Franklin: “Yes. It’s Ellen — I just love Ellen. Ellen rocks.”
LEON POST, St. Henry: “She’ll be fine. She’ll be great. She likes talking with people, and she gets along with people really well. I’ll miss Paula a little bit, but DeGeneres will be a little better. Abdul can go back to singing.”
RYAN BERGER, Miamisburg: “Sure, I guess. I think she’s funny.”
Permalink | Comments (4) | Post your comment | Categories: Entertainment

Comments
By Tony
January 11, 2010 8:13 AM | Link to this
Absolutely not…she is the reason that I have decided to no longer watch the show!
By Jim
January 11, 2010 9:28 AM | Link to this
I cannot believe they chose Ellen D to be a judge. She knows absolutely nothing about music and singing. I have always enjoyed watching ordinary people compete in this competition; but, like “Tony” I will NOT watch “Idol” this year. I hope their ratings suffer because of this incredibly poor decision.
By flipper
January 11, 2010 11:57 AM | Link to this
Just change the last letter in the last name and you’ve got your answer.
By seo lace
May 1, 2010 11:25 PM | Link to this
I am having a helluva time seeing wwws.spirngifelcnwsesun.com in pOeera 8.3, I just tohught I wuold eltf oyu knwo?