Latest featured videos from Journal-News.com
but that\'s not cricket | Book Nook
 

Home > Blogs > Book Nook > Archives > 2008 > July > 04 > Entry

but that’s not cricket

51LfC4TNeWL._SL500_AA240_.jpg

The critics have been falling all over themselves shouting the praises of “Netherland,” the new novel by Joseph O’Neill. A typical review in the New York Times exclaimed that “it has more life inside it than 10 very good novels.”

As the glowing reviews piled up I resisted this temptation — I questioned how this book could ever live up to the hype that it was getting? People were literally stopping me in the street to ask if I had read it yet? Finally, I gave in.

“Netherland” is the story of Hans, a Dutch banker living in New York City with his English wife and infant son. When 9/11 occurs the family is forced to relocate to the Chelsea Hotel. The destruction at the World Trade Center towers serves as the catalyst for the detonation of their marriage. Shortly thereafter, Hans watches numbly as his wife and child move back to England.

O’Neill employs a series of time shifts in “Netherland.” As the story begins Hans has just learned that his good friend Chuck has been murdered back in New York. Hans is living in London when a reporter from the New York Times calls to ask him about the late Chuck.

Learning about the deceased seems like a classic crime fiction opening. The dearly departed Chuck passed away in twisted fashion. Much of the book consists of flashbacks to the times that Hans and Chuck had spent together.

When his wife leaves him Hans becomes untethered, lost. Every other weekend he flies to England to visit his son. Back in New York he has too much time on his hands. He doesn’t seem to have any friends. By a chance circumstance Hans becomes involved with a group of men who play cricket every weekend.

These cricket players are all immigrants. Through cricket Hans meets Chuck Ramkissoon, a flamboyant wheeler dealer from Trinidad. They become friends. Chuck gives Hans driving lessons. It eventually dawns on Hans that Chuck is engaged in some criminal enterprises while using Hans as his driver.

O’Neill is an astute observer, gifted in his expression. Hans observes that “like an old door, every man past a certain age comes with historical warps and creaks of one kind or another, and a woman who wishes to put him to serious further use must expect to do a certain amount of sanding and planing.”

As Hans reflects on the collapse of his marriage he sees “that the steamboat of marriage must be fed incessantly with the coals of communication.” As his relationship languishes Hans becomes obsessed with playing cricket. Apparently, the author is a long-time cricket enthusiast.

Is “Netherland” an entertaining piece of fiction? Most definitely. Will it be honored as one of the classics, a great American novel? I think not. It reminded me of eating certain types of cuisine. It had some delicious flavors and textures but nothing that really stuck to this reviewer’s ribs. It lacked substance.

Even so, I enjoyed it.

Vick Mickunas

Permalink | Comments (2) | Post your comment | Categories: booms and busts

Comments

By victor mickunas

July 10, 2008 5:21 AM | Link to this

Thanks, Jan. Good points! CHILD 44 is another book that I have had sitting here unread for exactly that reason; it is overhyped. While the theory of the 10 year “seasoning” has merit I must say that from the standpoint of the publishing industry if that lag became common practice for readers the entire industry as we know it would collapse. If everybody waited 10 years to buy books then most publishers would go bankrupt and all those books would go out of print. So, it becomes a moot point. In 10 years nobody will even remember these books, right? Hard to tell. The authors will certainly remember them…

By Jan King

July 9, 2008 1:46 PM | Link to this

I just finished Netherland last night and then read your review. I read once that you should not read any book until 10 years after its debut. After just finishing two recent books that have been hyped alot I think I might adopt this theory myself. Child 44 and Netherland were good, I agree, but it is easy to read strong reviews and then be pretty disappointed. Good books but nothing great about them. I enjoy your column.
Post a comment



Remember me?


Commenting on this blog is moderated. Your blog will wait in a queue for approval by an administrator.


*HTML not allowed in comments. Your e-mail address is required.

 
Home | News | Sports | Entertainment | Opinion | Life | Recreation | Jobs | Cars | Homes
Advertising Media Kit | Online Ad Studio | Advertiser Tools | Customer Service | Our Partners | RSS | Site Map

Copyright © 2009 Cox Ohio Publishing, Dayton, Ohio, USA. All rights reserved.

By using this site, you accept the terms of our Visitors Agreement and Privacy Policy. You may wish to note our other business policies.

This website is ACAP-enabled